All methods combined
What happens if all of the previous card rating systems are combined using their rank as a point system and all of their ranks are added up and the lowest total rank wins? Here goes...and it's not all bad...but surely not the best that can be done. The problem with this one seems that total individual card numbers are inordinately driven by sellers trying to maximize profits. One more shot on the next page and it will be whatever it is.
All Ratings Combined | ||||||
Rank | Card | Player | Rating Points | |||
1 | 93 | Dave Baker | 28 | |||
2 | 133 | Tom Tracy | 44 | |||
3 | 103 | Bob St. Clair | 60 | |||
4 | 74 | Sam Baker | 74 | |||
5 | 139 | Allen Green | 86 | |||
6 | 28 | Del Shofner | 97 | |||
7 | 41 | Jess Richardson | 97 | |||
8 | 110 | Angelo Coia | 101 | |||
9 | 10 | Tom Moore | 112 | |||
10 | 145 | Jerry Tubbs | 115 | |||
11 | 34 | Tom Brookshier | 117 | |||
12 | 136 | Mike Connelly | 122 | |||
13 | 54 | Darris McCord | 123 | |||
14 | 164 | Art Hunter | 130 | |||
15 | 36 | Ted Dean | 136 | |||
16 | 117 | Larry Morris | 137 | |||
17 | 175 | Rip Hawkins | 138 | |||
18 | 181 | Dick Pesonen | 141 | |||
19 | 153 | Bill Koman | 146 | |||
20 | 169 | Jack Pardee | 159 | |||
21 | 59 | Joe Schmidt | 168 | |||
22 | 84 | Steve Myhra | 180 | |||
23 | 9 | Max McGee | 182 | |||
24 | 43 | Bobby Walston | 182 | |||
25 | 18 | Bob Gaiters | 183 | |||
26 | 24 | Joe Morrison | 183 | |||
27 | 48 | Jim Gibbons | 192 | |||
28 | 147 | Ed Cook | 192 | |||
29 | 29 | Y. A. Tittle | 194 | |||
30 | 193 | Joe Krakoski | 206 | |||
31 | 55 | Jim Martin | 216 | |||
32 | 47 | Gail Cogdill | 218 | |||
33 | 15 | Jesse Whittenton | 221 | |||
34 | 78 | Ordell Braase | 222 | |||
35 | 92 | John Brodie | 223 | |||
36 | 73 | Jim Ray Smith | 229 | |||
37 | 148 | John David Crow | 231 | |||
38 | 200 | Bob Toneff | 231 | |||
39 | 44 | Chuck Weber | 238 | |||
40 | 171 | Les Richter | 239 | |||
41 | 19 | Roosevelt Grier | 244 | |||
42 | 163 | Carroll Dale | 245 | |||
43 | 176 | Don Joyce | 255 | |||
44 | 82 | Lenny Moore | 259 | |||
45 | 75 | Paul Wiggin | 266 | |||
46 | 62 | Galen Fiss | 268 | |||
47 | 155 | Dale Meinert | 272 | |||
48 | 188 | Bill Anderson | 276 | |||
49 | 165 | John LoVetere | 279 | |||
50 | 111 | Mike Ditka | 280 | |||
51 | 123 | Bobby Joe Green | 282 | |||
52 | 192 | Jim Kerr | 282 | |||
53 | 186 | Frank Youso | 291 | |||
54 | 67 | Bobby Mitchell | 295 | |||
55 | 189 | Don Bosseler | 295 | |||
56 | 135 | Frank Clarke | 297 | |||
57 | 140 | Billy Howton | 298 | |||
58 | 119 | Bill Wade | 310 | |||
59 | 158 | Ralph Guglielmi | 313 | |||
60 | 183 | George Shaw | 315 | |||
61 | 174 | Grady Alderman | 316 | |||
62 | 68 | John Morrow | 318 | |||
63 | 25 | Dick Nolan | 325 | |||
64 | 35 | Jimmy Carr | 332 | |||
65 | 97 | Jim Johnson | 346 | |||
66 | 151 | Prentice Gautt | 354 | |||
67 | 104 | Monty Stickles | 356 | |||
68 | 46 | Howard Cassady | 362 | |||
69 | 154 | Larry Wilson | 366 | |||
70 | 60 | Harley Sewell | 381 | |||
71 | 96 | Matt Hazeltine | 381 | |||
72 | 190 | Fred Hageman | 389 | |||
73 | 157 | Sonny Randle | 397 | |||
74 | 61 | Jim Brown | 398 | |||
75 | 122 | Buddy Dial | 404 | |||
76 | 198 | Norm Snead | 418 | |||
77 | 112 | Joe Fortunato | 427 | |||
78 | 66 | Gene Hickerson | 432 | |||
79 | 91 | Bruce Bosley | 433 | |||
80 | 129 | John Nisby | 434 | |||
81 | 58 | Nick Pietrosante | 444 | |||
82 | 94 | Tommy Davis | 450 | |||
83 | 26 | Andy Robustelli | 452 | |||
84 | 13 | Jim Taylor | 459 | |||
85 | 8 | Jerry Kramer | 460 | |||
86 | 63 | Bob Gain | 464 | |||
87 | 2 | Boyd Dowler | 466 | |||
88 | 127 | Gene Lipscomb | 470 | |||
89 | 22 | Cliff Livingston | 472 | |||
90 | 51 | Dick Lane | 472 | |||
91 | 121 | Preston Carpenter | 474 | |||
92 | 182 | Karl Rubke | 474 | |||
93 | 23 | Dick Lynch | 486 | |||
94 | 87 | Bill Pellington | 494 | |||
95 | 79 | Art Donovan | 499 | |||
96 | 172 | Frank Ryan | 503 | |||
97 | 141 | Bob Lilly | 510 | |||
98 | 177 | Bill Lapham | 510 | |||
99 | 146 | J. W. Lockett | 514 | |||
100 | 118 | Richie Petitbon | 516 | |||
101 | 187 | Bill Bishop | 516 | |||
102 | 80 | Dee Mackey | 522 | |||
103 | 107 | Ed Brown | 523 | |||
104 | 130 | John Reger | 524 | |||
105 | 42 | Leo Sugar | 529 | |||
106 | 173 | Frank Varrichione | 529 | |||
107 | 89 | Dick Szymanski | 538 | |||
108 | 102 | J.D. Smith | 538 | |||
109 | 116 | Johnny Morris | 540 | |||
110 | 45 | Ed Khayat | 546 | |||
111 | 98 | Billy Kilmer | 552 | |||
112 | 81 | Gino Marchetti | 555 | |||
113 | 90 | John Unitas | 560 | |||
114 | 109 | Rick Casares | 560 | |||
115 | 199 | Andy Stynchula | 560 | |||
116 | 11 | Jim Ringo | 572 | |||
117 | 85 | Jimmy Orr | 576 | |||
118 | 191 | Sam Horner | 577 | |||
119 | 83 | Jim Mutscheller | 583 | |||
120 | 56 | Earl Morrall | 589 | |||
121 | 194 | Fred Dugan | 592 | |||
122 | 185 | Mel Triplett | 602 | |||
123 | 168 | Ed Meador | 603 | |||
124 | 12 | Bart Starr | 607 | |||
125 | 105 | Abe Woodson | 611 | |||
126 | 126 | Bobby Layne | 616 | |||
127 | 132 | George Tarasovic | 627 | |||
128 | 3 | Bill Forester | 629 | |||
129 | 99 | Jerry Mertens | 629 | |||
130 | 195 | John Paluck | 631 | |||
131 | 38 | Tommy McDonald | 633 | |||
132 | 72 | Dick Schafrath | 645 | |||
133 | 101 | R.C. Owens | 646 | |||
134 | 69 | Bernie Parrish | 652 | |||
135 | 27 | Kyle Rote | 654 | |||
136 | 106 | Doug Atkins | 655 | |||
137 | 65 | Mike McCormack | 656 | |||
138 | 64 | Jim Houston | 660 | |||
139 | 159 | Joe Childress | 662 | |||
140 | 100 | Frank Morze | 670 | |||
141 | 137 | L.G. Dupre | 672 | |||
142 | 120 | Maury Youmans | 676 | |||
143 | 37 | Sonny Jurgensen | 679 | |||
144 | 162 | Zeke Bratkowski | 682 | |||
145 | 86 | Jim Parker | 687 | |||
146 | 138 | Bob Fry | 698 | |||
147 | 77 | Bob Boyd | 700 | |||
148 | 170 | Jim Phillips | 709 | |||
149 | 124 | Mike Henry | 711 | |||
150 | 131 | Mike Sandusky | 714 | |||
151 | 150 | Frank Fuller | 720 | |||
152 | 49 | Bill Glass | 726 | |||
153 | 52 | Yale Lary | 732 | |||
154 | 161 | Dick Bass | 732 | |||
155 | 40 | Pete Retzlaff | 733 | |||
156 | 134 | Glynn Gregory | 734 | |||
157 | 115 | Stan Jones | 738 | |||
158 | 180 | Dave Middleton | 742 | |||
159 | 114 | Bill George | 745 | |||
160 | 167 | Ollie Matson | 748 | |||
161 | 179 | Hugh McElhenny | 748 | |||
162 | 71 | Ray Renfro | 752 | |||
163 | 88 | Alex Sandusky | 756 | |||
164 | 20 | Sam Huff | 765 | |||
165 | 196 | Vince Promuto | 765 | |||
166 | 144 | Don Perkins | 766 | |||
167 | 5 | Dave Hanner | 782 | |||
168 | 16 | Erich Barnes | 787 | |||
169 | 53 | Dan Lewis | 790 | |||
170 | 149 | Sam Etcheverry | 790 | |||
171 | 156 | Ed Henke | 791 | |||
172 | 142 | Don Meredith | 805 | |||
173 | 1 | Dan Currie | 808 | |||
174 | 70 | Milt Plum | 810 | |||
175 | 125 | John Henry Johnson | 811 | |||
176 | 166 | Lamar Lundy | 811 | |||
177 | 17 | Roosevelt Brown | 813 | |||
178 | 14 | Fuzzy Thurston | 818 | |||
179 | 128 | Lou Michaels | 821 | |||
180 | 4 | Forrest Gregg | 829 | |||
181 | 184 | Fran Tarkenton | 831 | |||
182 | 197 | Joe Rutgens | 839 | |||
183 | 21 | Jim Katcavage | 842 | |||
184 | 6 | Paul Hornung | 849 | |||
185 | 108 | J.C. Caroline | 849 | |||
186 | 31 | Billy Ray Barnes | 853 | |||
187 | 32 | Maxie Baughan | 854 | |||
188 | 76 | Raymond Berry | 855 | |||
189 | 30 | Alex Webster | 858 | |||
190 | 178 | Tommy Mason | 866 | |||
191 | 57 | Jim Ninowski | 870 | |||
192 | 7 | Henry Jordan | 887 | |||
193 | 152 | Jimmy Hill | 893 | |||
194 | 33 | Chuck Bednarik | 904 | |||
195 | 160 | Jon Arnett | 907 | |||
196 | 95 | Bob Harrison | 925 | |||
197 | 143 | Dick Moegle | 932 | |||
198 | 39 | Clarence Peaks | 937 | |||
199 | 50 | Alex Karras | 944 | |||
200 | 113 | Willie Galimore | 967 |