Player to Panel Rating System

This method seems logical in that a card's scarcity is based solely on the scarcity of the panels on which the card resides. A point system is assigned to each product (brand and size) based on the number of cards in the dataset that appear on that panel. Grape Nuts 11 oz. have the fewest number of cards in the groups of panels, so that product is assigned a 1; Oat Flakes 10 oz. is next lowest so it gets a 2 and so it goes through all 20 products. The issue with this method is that while there may be a reasonable disparity between the actual number of cards available between Bran Flakes 11 oz. cards and Post Tens cards, there is only a three point differential on the rating list. Still, it is an interesting exercise with interesting results. The panel point list is shown first followed by the card list with their assigned points from scarcest on up.

Product Point List
Points		Product
1		GN11
2		OF10
3		BF11
4		RB10
5		PT8
6		P10
7		AB¾
8		SCCF10
9		GNF16
10		GN16
11		RK10
12		BF16
13		AB13
14		GNF12
15		RB14
16		PT12
17		SC14
18		AB8
19		SC9
20		PT18

 

Player to Panel Rating
Rank	Card		Player	Panel Rating
1	93		Dave Baker	3
2	74		Sam Baker	7
3	133		Tom Tracy	7
4	169		Jack Pardee	7
5	54		Darris McCord	8
6	24		Joe Morrison	9
7	29		Y. A. Tittle	9
8	59		Joe Schmidt	9
9	10		Tom Moore	10
10	34		Tom Brookshier	10
11	103		Bob St. Clair	10
12	139		Allen Green	10
13	145		Jerry Tubbs	10
14	41		Jess Richardson	11
15	48		Jim Gibbons	11
16	110		Angelo Coia	11
17	153		Bill Koman	11
18	181		Dick Pesonen	11
19	43		Bobby Walston	12
20	62		Galen Fiss	12
21	84		Steve Myhra	12
22	117		Larry Morris	12
23	136		Mike Connelly	12
24	15		Jesse Whittenton	13
25	25		Dick Nolan	13
26	28		Del Shofner	13
27	36		Ted Dean	13
28	44		Chuck Weber	13
29	111		Mike Ditka	13
30	148		John David Crow	13
31	18		Bob Gaiters	14
32	75		Paul Wiggin	14
33	78		Ordell Braase	14
34	147		Ed Cook	14
35	164		Art Hunter	14
36	176		Don Joyce	14
37	188		Bill Anderson	14
38	67		Bobby Mitchell	15
39	73		Jim Ray Smith	15
40	158		Ralph Guglielmi	15
41	165		John LoVetere	15
42	175		Rip Hawkins	15
43	193		Joe Krakoski	15
44	47		Gail Cogdill	16
45	82		Lenny Moore	16
46	92		John Brodie	16
47	97		Jim Johnson	16
48	123		Bobby Joe Green	16
49	155		Dale Meinert	16
50	157		Sonny Randle	16
51	186		Frank Youso	16
52	200		Bob Toneff	16
53	55		Jim Martin	17
54	61		Jim Brown	17
55	135		Frank Clarke	17
56	163		Carroll Dale	17
57	171		Les Richter	17
58	174		Grady Alderman	17
59	19		Roosevelt Grier	18
60	46		Howard Cassady	18
61	68		John Morrow	18
62	112		Joe Fortunato	18
63	122		Buddy Dial	18
64	151		Prentice Gautt	18
65	183		George Shaw	18
66	192		Jim Kerr	18
67	9		Max McGee	19
68	35		Jimmy Carr	19
69	51		Dick Lane	19
70	94		Tommy Davis	19
71	96		Matt Hazeltine	19
72	98		Billy Kilmer	19
73	129		John Nisby	19
74	140		Billy Howton	19
75	13		Jim Taylor	20
76	104		Monty Stickles	20
77	107		Ed Brown	20
78	119		Bill Wade	20
79	121		Preston Carpenter	20
80	154		Larry Wilson	20
81	189		Don Bosseler	20
82	198		Norm Snead	20
83	8		Jerry Kramer	21
84	80		Dee Mackey	21
85	87		Bill Pellington	21
86	127		Gene Lipscomb	21
87	141		Bob Lilly	21
88	187		Bill Bishop	21
89	195		John Paluck	21
90	58		Nick Pietrosante	22
91	63		Bob Gain	22
92	66		Gene Hickerson	22
93	99		Jerry Mertens	22
94	162		Zeke Bratkowski	22
95	172		Frank Ryan	22
96	190		Fred Hageman	22
97	22		Cliff Livingston	23
98	90		John Unitas	23
99	115		Stan Jones	23
100	182		Karl Rubke	23
101	2		Boyd Dowler	24
102	109		Rick Casares	24
103	118		Richie Petitbon	24
104	132		George Tarasovic	24
105	23		Dick Lynch	25
106	69		Bernie Parrish	25
107	79		Art Donovan	25
108	81		Gino Marchetti	25
109	85		Jimmy Orr	25
110	89		Dick Szymanski	25
111	116		Johnny Morris	25
112	126		Bobby Layne	25
113	173		Frank Varrichione	25
114	3		Bill Forester	26
115	42		Leo Sugar	26
116	65		Mike McCormack	26
117	83		Jim Mutscheller	26
118	91		Bruce Bosley	26
119	100		Frank Morze	26
120	130		John Reger	26
121	137		L.G. Dupre	26
122	11		Jim Ringo	27
123	12		Bart Starr	27
124	37		Sonny Jurgensen	27
125	38		Tommy McDonald	27
126	53		Dan Lewis	27
127	60		Harley Sewell	27
128	64		Jim Houston	27
129	71		Ray Renfro	27
130	105		Abe Woodson	27
131	106		Doug Atkins	27
132	124		Mike Henry	27
133	131		Mike Sandusky	27
134	146		J. W. Lockett	27
135	159		Joe Childress	27
136	168		Ed Meador	27
137	177		Bill Lapham	27
138	194		Fred Dugan	27
139	199		Andy Stynchula	27
140	20		Sam Huff	28
141	56		Earl Morrall	28
142	102		J.D. Smith	28
143	134		Glynn Gregory	28
144	166		Lamar Lundy	28
145	167		Ollie Matson	28
146	170		Jim Phillips	28
147	180		Dave Middleton	28
148	191		Sam Horner	28
149	5		Dave Hanner	29
150	26		Andy Robustelli	29
151	27		Kyle Rote	29
152	40		Pete Retzlaff	29
153	45		Ed Khayat	29
154	49		Bill Glass	29
155	72		Dick Schafrath	29
156	88		Alex Sandusky	29
157	120		Maury Youmans	29
158	128		Lou Michaels	29
159	138		Bob Fry	29
160	149		Sam Etcheverry	29
161	161		Dick Bass	29
162	185		Mel Triplett	29
163	196		Vince Promuto	29
164	52		Yale Lary	30
165	77		Bob Boyd	30
166	86		Jim Parker	30
167	144		Don Perkins	30
168	150		Frank Fuller	30
169	152		Jimmy Hill	30
170	1		Dan Currie	31
171	14		Fuzzy Thurston	31
172	108		J.C. Caroline	31
173	125		John Henry Johnson	31
174	156		Ed Henke	31
175	179		Hugh McElhenny	31
176	30		Alex Webster	32
177	95		Bob Harrison	32
178	101		R.C. Owens	32
179	178		Tommy Mason	32
180	21		Jim Katcavage	33
181	32		Maxie Baughan	33
182	57		Jim Ninowski	33
183	114		Bill George	33
184	160		Jon Arnett	34
185	70		Milt Plum	35
186	76		Raymond Berry	35
187	142		Don Meredith	35
188	143		Dick Moegle	35
189	197		Joe Rutgens	35
190	17		Roosevelt Brown	36
191	31		Billy Ray Barnes	37
192	39		Clarence Peaks	38
193	50		Alex Karras	38
194	184		Fran Tarkenton	38
195	16		Erich Barnes	39
196	33		Chuck Bednarik	39
197	113		Willie Galimore	39
198	7		Henry Jordan	43
199	4		Forrest Gregg	45
200	6		Paul Hornung	46